Improvised Club

Four damage for two mana is meaningful reach or removal, but sacrificing material is a steep cost versus Modern's efficient burn and removal.

Could be wrong if Artifact-heavy lists may find enough expendable permanents to make it a recurring finisher rather than a niche experiment.

Legacy's mana-efficient removal and fast games make a two-mana, sacrifice-dependent 4-damage spell difficult to justify.

Could be wrong if A dedicated artifact-sacrifice shell could value turning disposable material into direct damage more than expected.

Expendable artifacts can turn the drawback into acceptable 4-damage removal or reach, but it remains less reliable than normal one-card answers.

Could be wrong if If artifact decks lack sufficiently disposable permanents, the built-in two-for-one will keep it out of competitive lists.

It is a serviceable one-shot sacrifice outlet that converts fodder into removal, but four damage and a single use are modest in multiplayer.

Could be wrong if Dense death-trigger or artifact-recursion shells may value the sacrifice trigger enough to make it a stronger niche inclusion.

Instant-speed 4 damage can profitably trade a token or weak artifact for a better creature, but it is poor without expendable material.

Could be wrong if Token density, artifact fodder, and format speed are unknown; those determine whether the sacrifice is manageable.