Boughside Wanderers

Mono Green Landfall can cast it, but a 4/4 that finds only one permanent from four is far below Eddymurk Crab's impact and needs later land drops.

Could be wrong if Green ramp or landfall payoffs may make its permanent selection and +2/+2 triggers more relevant than the revealed context suggests.

Six mana for a 4/4 and one conditional permanent is too slow; even fringe five-mana threats such as Elder Gargaroth offer much stronger immediate value.

Could be wrong if An unshown ramp shell that specifically wants a permanent-selection creature could create a narrow home.

It has neither a cost reduction nor immediate board swing; it is dramatically less impactful than Modern's playable large creatures such as Generous Ent or Primeval Titan.

Could be wrong if A new efficient cheat-into-play engine could alter its casting-cost problem, though its ETB remains modest.

A six-mana fair 4/4 with minor selection is not credible beside Legacy's highly efficient threats and engines; it lacks Murktide Regent's rate or Atraxa's payoff.

Could be wrong if Only a presently unknown dedicated landfall or creature-cheating shell could justify testing it.

Elves can potentially reach six mana, but this is a weak payoff: one permanent from four and a 4/4 compares poorly with Generous Ent's immediate fixing or Avenging Hunter's initiative.

Could be wrong if If the set adds unusually effective common landfall support, its body and selection could be a better green-ramp payoff.

Landfall decks can use the body and permanent selection, but six mana for only one top-four hit is replaceable and well below broad value engines like Seedborn Muse.

Could be wrong if A commander that repeatedly flickers creatures or rewards large temporary power could make the ETB and landfall package more attractive.

A 4/4 that usually provides a permanent is reliable late-game value, and landfall can create strong attacks, though six mana and delayed scaling prevent premium status.

Could be wrong if Unknown format speed, fixing, removal, and green ramp density could move this substantially in either direction.